Notes on "Hermeneutics and Literature" (Jonathan Culler in The Cambridge Companion to Hermeneutics)
My usual disclaimer for notes such as these: this is neither a critical nor an academic appraisal of the work, but a personal response to aid my own construction of meaning. The most interesting part of the chapter is the discussion of the exchange between Cleanth Brooks and Douglas Bush regarding the interpretation of Andrew Marvell's "An Horatian Ode upon Cromwell's Return from Ireland". Ought the poem be read in its historical context with the intention of the author in mind (Bush), or ought it be viewed primarily as a work of poetry (Brooks)? One short passage is used as an example: "And now the Irish are asham'd To see themselves in one Year tam'd: So much one Man can do, That does both act and know. They can affirm his Praises best, And have, though overcome confest How good he is, how just, And fit for highest trust." Is this Marvell exhibiting wishful thinking in believing that the defeated Irish now share the English view of Cromwell, or gri...





Comments
Post a Comment